Assistant District Attorney Kourtney Bell. From Bell's LinkedIn page.

Yesterday, Judge Eric Fleming postponed the plea hearing for Troy McAlister (the man who killed Hanako Abe and Elizabeth Platt in 2020 while fleeing a robbery in a stolen car) not once, but twice. The hearing was set to start at 1:30 p.m. PST, but when the Zoom camera went live, Fleming told attendees that he had given Assistant District Attorney Kourtney Bell permission to be in another courtroom and pushed the McAlister case to 3 p.m.

“I understand a disposition has been reached in this case,” Fleming said, asking if representatives of both victims’ families were present. They were, as was Kaoru Tamura, the court-appointed Japanese translator assigned to Hiroko Abe, the mother of victim Hanako, after Fleming questioned Assistant District Attorney Kourtney Bell at a previous hearing as to why he hadn’t done so prior. Over nearly six years, Tasha Yorozu, an attorney who doesn’t represent Abe, has voluntarily translated, even during official hearings, emails, and meetings with the District Attorney’s Office.

At approximately 3:30 p.m., Fleming read the charges and pleas. McAlister would receive 20 years in prison for Hanako’s death and 20 years for Elizabeth’s death — the maximum sentence for gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated — and “admit” to one of his prior three strikes. He would also receive 16 months for the stolen vehicle. “That’s not 40 years. The 20 years for each count will be served concurrently,” Fleming explained, meaning that McAlister would serve just 10 years per life he took.

“I am in receipt of your letter to the D.A., Mrs. Abe, and that you believe it’s unfair. That you’re perplexed. You ask four questions and prepared a letter to me, and you asked, ‘Why did the DA decline a malice murder charge which would have sent the case to the Attorney General’s Office?’” A Watson murder is a second-degree murder charge under California Penal Code 187 for a DUI driver who causes a death while knowing that impaired driving is dangerous to life. It carries 15 years to life in prison, and you can be charged even if you have never had a DUI before (McAlister has had multiple DUI charges over the course of his 40-year criminal history). Fleming asked Bell why they hadn’t recharged McAlister. “Prosecutorial discretion,” Bell said. “The DA declined to pursue malice murder charges.”

In a phone interview after yesterday’s hearing, Yorozu, who translated an Oct. 5, 2026, Zoom call with Bell (the first contact Abe had with the District Attorney’s office under Brooke Jenkins), said that Bell told Abe the DA didn’t want to change the original charging document of former DA Chesa Boudin.

According to Bell, in 2025, a grand jury judge allowed Jenkins to change Boudin’s charging document to include a Watson murder and McAlister’s prior strikes but said if they did so the case would be transferred to the California Attorney General’s jurisdiction. Bell said the D.A. declined, stating, “We will not change the charging document because these deaths occurred in San Francisco and we want to try this case, not the Attorney General.” The judge asked twice if the D.A. was certain about their decision, and Bell indicated that they were.

In a subsequent email, Bell also went into detail about McAlister’s public defender, Scott Grant, filing a motion to disqualify Jenkins from prosecuting the case in 2023, contending that Jenkins’s “personal and political motivations have undermined her and her office’s ability to prosecute this matter fairly and impartially.” In the motion, Grant lists several reasons why he believes there is a conflict of interest between Jenkins and McAlister, including the fact that Jenkins “improperly sent sensitive files related to the case to fellow Assistant District Attorney Don du Bain’s personal email.” Neither Jenkins nor du Bain had a direct connection to the case under Boudin, but details they obtained were later used by them as part of the effort that led to the successful effort of Boudin. Again, Jenkins fought the attempt to move the case to the Attorney General and won.

EMAIL SHOWS BELL MISLED JUDGE ABOUT ACCEPTING PLEA DEAL

Fleming gave Abe a chance to speak through her new translator, telling the judge that she heard from Bell for the first time on that Oct. 5, 2026, Zoom call when she was stunned to learn that the District Attorney’s Office wanted to accept the public defender’s plea offer just 10 days before McAlister’s trial was set to begin.

“Did District Attorney Jenkins speak to Mrs. Abe?” Fleming asked.

“Multiple attempts were made. [Mrs. Abe] would ask questions and we would answer them, then she would ask more questions, and we would answer them…” Bell replied, sounding slightly annoyed. He then informed the judge that Abe had refused the meeting with Jenkins.  

“Were you aware the elected DA wanted to meet with you?” Fleming asked.

“I received an email in the middle of the plea agreement, and we did meet [with Bell]. And at that time, I understood they wouldn’t enter a plea agreement without input from the families. I found out later they had already entered into a plea agreement. From that time onwards, I no longer felt I could believe anything I was told,” Abe said.

“Did you refuse to meet with District Attorney Jenkins?” Fleming asked.

“It wasn’t right after that — there was a hearing where you said we should engage in a discussion and that’s what I was willing to do. After that first meeting with Bell, I thought he would keep us in the loop, [but] it was as if that meeting didn’t happen and they had entered already in the plea deal…”

“She was told before the plea was entered into?” Fleming asked Bell, then he turned to Abe. “This court would never agree to a plea until we know what the family feels. That’s why you’re here today.”

Bell asserted to the judge that no plea agreement was made without Abe’s input, then said, “We need to continue this tomorrow.” It was 4:15, and McAlister was due back at county jail. 

Bell, who always seems distracted or in a hurry to get to other courtrooms, lied to Judge Fleming about not having accepted the plea offer, or perhaps he forgot about the email he sent to Abe and Yorozu’s team the night before the first plea hearing, as detailed in a previous article in The Voice. 

At 11:09 a.m. PST on the morning of Oct. 6, 2026, Bell sent an email thanking Abe for her “thoughtful email” and ensuring that her concerns would be expressed “when we meet regarding whether the case should resolve or proceed to trial.” 

The next evening, on Oct. 7 at 6:10 p.m. PST, Bell sent another email. “I am reaching out because I wanted to inform you that a decision has been made regarding the McAlister case. After careful consideration of the circumstances of the case, the evidence, and the available sentencing options, the District Attorney’s Office has decided to resolve the case,” Bell wrote decisively. “I recognize that this may not be the outcome you wanted, particularly given the devastating loss your family has experienced. This was not an easy decision. After carefully evaluating the case and the available options, we believe this resolution represents an appropriate and substantial measure of accountability under the circumstances…”

At 7:04 p.m., Haruko DeArth from Yorozu’s team responded: 

“Ms. Abe has asked us to express her shock at your office’s decision, especially since you had asked her to provide her thoughts on whether to accept the plea offer by the hearing date, which was rescheduled to tomorrow at 9 a.m. …”

There was no response from Bell.

Susan Dyer Reynolds is the editorial director of The Voice of San Francisco and an award-winning journalist. Follow her on X @TheVOSF.