A proposal from the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) to install a Lyft bike rental station near Aquatic Park, which drew criticism from seniors at the San Francisco Senior Center at Aquatic Park, was withdrawn last Friday at a public hearing.
According to SFMTA documents, the agency proposed the station in the buffer zone of a newly installed two-way bike lane near the intersection of Beach and Polk streets. SFMTA Chief Spokesperson Erica Kato said in a statement that the agency withdrew the proposed station so they can discuss the proposal more with the Fisherman’s Wharf Community Benefits District.
Over two dozen seniors with signs objecting to the proposed bike station because of safety concerns protested Thursday morning, a day before the SFMTA’s Engineering Public Hearing.
Some of the signs read “Don’t Over Senior Safety” and “Protect The Aquatic Park Walkway.” One of the organizers of the protest, Jeffrey Tong, who visits the center, said there were concerns about the possible availability of Lyft electric bikes for rental to the public at the station. The Lyft e-bikes have a pedal-assist system that can go up to 20 mph.
“What they’re doing now, what they’re proposing, is elevating it up to an electric bicycle lane, which is so dangerous,” Tong said. He added that adding a bike station at the proposed location would create an “electric bike superhighway.”
There were also numerous letters from seniors against the proposed bike station as well as a petition.
Anh Le, a protest organizer, independent journalist, and visitor to the senior center for activities, said in an email statement that the bike station would be an “obstacle” for seniors trying to enter the center.
“Putting the Lyft E-Bike Station in front of the Center is dangerous to the Seniors,” Le said. “It’s a danger to the Seniors’ physical safety. It would pose Accessibility Risks for the seniors at the front entrance.”
Le added that several of the seniors have impairments and some have to use either a cane, walker, or wheelchair.
The group of seniors also said they had only heard about the proposal a week before the public hearing because of a flier posted near the proposed site. Kato said the transportation agency sent mailers to the senior center, as well as to residents, tenants, and owners within approximately 250 feet of the proposed site. The agency’s goal is to send out the mailers about 10 days before the public hearing.
As for why the site was first proposed, Kato said it met the bikeshare criteria, including surrounding land-use density, proximity to the city’s bike network, and existing demand for rental bikes.
“By locating it in the buffer to the newly established bikeway, this would also help provide improved safety, with more separation between bicyclists and other road users,” Kato added.
But some seniors and volunteers did not see it that way. Emily Lam, a senior who takes sewing classes at the center, opposed the proposed bike station. “Putting Lyft e-bikes here will make it difficult for senior citizens to safely walk,” Lam said.
Kato said there was a planned alternative location, but at least for now, a Lyft bike rental station will not be installed at the originally proposed site.
