Sam Claflin plays Fred, Daisy Ridley plays Clara and Johnny Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge in Ebenezer from Paramount Pictures. | © 2026 Paramount Pictures. All Rights Reserved.

In the immortal words of Ebenezer Scrooge, “Bah! Humbug!” Ebenezer, the latest feature film based on A Christmas Carol, was released in theaters this past weekend, just in time for the start of the winter holiday season. Was another movie or television interpretation of Charles Dickens’s 1843 novella necessary when so many memorable ones have preceded it? Maybe not, but the venerable tale of a Victoria-era miser’s Yuletide change of heart is in the public domain, so it’s fair game for remake after remake.

Sticking to the basics of the Dickens classic, Ebenezer is hardly an innovative take on the material. It’s most notable as a vehicle for veteran star Johnny Depp, whose performance as bitter, curmudgeonly businessman Ebenezer Scrooge marks his first live-action role in an English-language film since 2020. As seen in the tabloids and on TMZ, Depp has been beset by unsavory relationship scandals and legal tussles over the past decade. With that recent history in mind, his appearance in a family-friendly project like Ebenezer feels like the first leg of a redemption tour. Conveniently, he’s playing the lead in the story of a flawed man whose character arc is all about redemption.

The greedy, misanthropic Scrooge is as familiar a personage as any in literature, and his conversion to decency and generosity comes after a succession of Christmas Eve visits from ghosts, including his late partner, Jacob Marley. As the spirits show Scrooge his past, present, and future, he sees how his ambition undermined a youthful romance and his descent into cruelty resulted in a lonely, solitary life and bleak demise. These visions compel him to change his ways. Regardless of the different settings in the various screen adaptations of A Christmas Carol, the basics remain the same.

An abundance of Scrooges

Some of the versions are true to the Victorian period of the book. They include 1951’s Scrooge, a very straightforward British production with Alistair Sim as the quintessential Ebenezer, and 1970’s Scrooge, a musical starring Albert Finney as the dour penny-pincher. Michael Caine played Scrooge opposite a cast of beloved puppets (Kermit the Frog, Miss Piggy, Fozzie Bear, and others) in the musical comedy The Muppet Christmas Carol. Scrooged modernized Dickens with Bill Murray as Frank Cross, a ruthless TV executive haunted by ghostly visitations that mirror those in his network’s upcoming live broadcast of A Christmas Carol. On the animated side, Scrooge McDuck was the old tightwad in Mickey’s Christmas Carol, and Mr. Magoo was you-know-who in Mr. Magoo’s Christmas Carol. 

Patrick Stewart, George C. Scott, and Jim Carrey are among the other renowned actors who have portrayed Scrooge. That’s some heady company. Now, Depp has joined the group, and he does a good job as the wealthy, cold-hearted financier in Ebenezer, even if he doesn’t break new ground. He virtually disappears into the part, and it’s not just because of the exceedingly believable old-age makeup. Adding to the sheen, Depp’s costars are an accomplished bunch. Ian McKellen (The Lord of the Rings, X-Men) is Marley; Rupert Grint (Harry Potter) is Scrooge’s abused clerk Bob Cratchit; Andrea Riseborough (Birdman, Black Mirror) is the spooky Ghost of Christmas Past; Tramell Tillman (Severance) is the sly Ghost of Christmas Present; Sam Claflin (Peaky Blinders, Enola Holmes) is Scrooge’s earnest nephew Fred; and Daisy Ridley (Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker) is Fred’s supportive wife.

From the gloomy opening in Scrooge and Marley’s London office on Christmas Eve 1836 to the supernatural doings exactly seven years later, and to Ebenezer’s climactic about-face on Christmas morning, director Ti West leans into the yarn’s phantasmagorical vibe. The macabre presentation of the four ghosts fits the uncanny nature of the plot, and its scary/spectral quality isn’t far from the rest of West’s filmography, which has primarily been in the horror genre. As one would hope, the art direction and special effects are first-class.

Tweaking a familiar tale

With all the prior efforts to turn A Christmas Carol into a motion picture or television program, it’s unsurprising that Ebenezer screenwriter Nathaniel Halpern tried a tweak or two to freshen up or expand the scope of the narrative. Some of the minor changes work. A scene showing Marley’s demise elevated by McKellen’s subtlety, and the segment with young Scrooge (Arthur Conti) tumbling for and then losing the love of his life, Belle (Ellie Bamber), is sweet. The few random bits of slapstick aren’t quite as effective, although it seems like Depp welcomed the chance to do a handful of broader, sillier moments.

If you’ve never read A Christmas Carol nor seen previous dramatizations of it, Ebenezer isn’t a bad introduction. Or you could go for Alistair Sim’s Scrooge, which is as close to a cinematic archetype as you’ll find. Conversely, if you know the details of Scrooge’s spiritual journey, have had your fill of it, and would like to see it in a radically different (and very funny) light, you might want to seek out Blackadder’s Christmas Carol. This rather brilliant made-for-TV parody of the Dickens book features comedian Rowan Atkinson’s history-lampooning Blackadder persona as Ebenezer. The twist is that he starts out as the kindest, most generous man in London until the Christmas Eve visitation by those pesky ghosts reveals that everybody in his life has been taking advantage of him, and he decides to strike back with gleeful abandon. Humbug indeed!

Ebenezer is currently in theaters.

Michael Snyder is a print and broadcast journalist who covers pop culture on “The Mark Thompson Show,” via YouTube, iTunes and I Heart Radio, and on “Michael Snyder's Culture Blast,” via GABNet.net...