No sound is louder than when public officials turn a deaf ear to the sincerely expressed concerns of constituents. That’s the takeaway from the Nov. 17 San Francisco Unified School District board meeting.
The superintendent and most of the school board hid behind the supposed pillar of good governance and denied parents even a chance to discuss their concerns or an explanation for the district’s action on an agreement on the agenda.
Only one school board member, Supryia Ray, spoke up and tried to address parents’ safety concerns, to no avail.
Here is what happened:
Parents … many, many parents. … told the school board they were concerned for the safety of their children and reported antisemitic experiences in SFUSD. They asked the school district to ensure that an agreement on the agenda would not make matters worse.
A simple agreement is at issue: to support Arab and Muslim students through workshops and counseling. Services include cultural awareness and celebration, youth empowerment, and leadership development.
It includes a curriculum not created by the school district.
The agreement, on its face, is just routine, and because it could be passed off as routine, the district put the item on its consent agenda, which prohibits debate and is supposed to be reserved for routine matters that do not need discussion.
Controversial items should not be on the consent agenda.
But nothing is quite so simple in San Francisco, which has a history of claims of antisemitism and an ethnic studies homegrown curriculum so troubling it had to be scrapped.
And indeed, the public quickly identified the controversy and told the school district their concerns before the meeting.
What’s so concerning?
A close look at the agreement reveals it is with the Services, a sister organization of the Arab and Resource and Organizing Center (AROC). It describes itself on its website:
Our DNA carries a century of radical traditions in people-powered movements and grassroots organizing.
AROC has a controversial history with SFUSD involving student walkouts and political activity. Its website explains that its youth leaders gain the organizing skills to successfully lead campaigns that advance racial and economic justice.
With this knowledge, the district should have heeded the community’s calls: Instead of leaving it on the consent calendar at this meeting, take more time to ensure the rights of all students are protected.
The district needs to look carefully at these items:
– Was it a routine item ready for passage with no debate?
– What is or isn’t allowed under the draft Memo of Understanding?
– What organizing and political activities are included?
– What is allowed under law?
– What is the oversight mechanism?
– What activities are under teacher supervision and what activities are not?
– Is the school district responsible for the safety of students and the scope of activities off school premises?
– Are there provisions that ensure all students feel safe and valued?
These questions should be asked of any organization proposing the same kind of activities.
The absence of discussion keeps the public in the dark.
Alas. The district took the road most traveled: Be reactive rather than proactive.
Instead of creating confidence with a thorough, transparent review, the school board decided not to discuss it at all.
Parental concerns over student safety should never be dismissed in this way.
Let’s be clear: No one objects to culturally responsive education for Arab and Muslim students. No one.
You can watch the Board of Education meeting here.
