San Francisco transportation officials approved a contract to upgrade the camera system on Muni buses that records vehicles blocking transit-only lanes and parked in bus stops, which transit planners said will help ease the process of finding potential violations and sending out citations.
On Tuesday, the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency’s Board of Directors approved a $55 million contract with Hayden AI Technologies, Inc. for three years, with three one-year options to extend the contract. Officials said the new system will be less cumbersome for reviewing potential violations than the current system, which is nearly 20 years old.
All of Muni’s buses are equipped with mounted, front-facing Muni bus cameras that are continuously recording, saving the video and data for review by a parking control officer.
Michael Rhodes, the acting director of the SFMTA’s Muni Forward Program, said staff manually retrieve the video, which parking control officers then review for potential violations. An SFMTA staff report said officers are reviewing thousands of hours of video footage each year. If a violation is found, the officer will then prepare the citation to be mailed.
“The outcomes of that are that the current program is quite labor-intensive,” Rhodes said in his presentation to the board. “We’re not able to effectively provide a deterrent to double parking in the transit lane across the city, and it limits our scalability as state law has enabled us to enforce more violations, such as transit stops that are not next to transit lanes.”
The SFMTA issues about 6,000 to 8,000 citations per year, a small fraction of the violations that occur, Rhodes said.
As part of the new technology, the video will only record when a potential violation is detected, and instead of a staff member having to retrieve the video from each bus, the data from the cameras are wirelessly transmitted. The system will also create “automated evidence packages” for officers to review potential violations and automate the process of mailing out the citations, the staff report said.
Rhodes said the goal of the program was not to issue citations, but to keep the transit lanes and bus stops cleared.
“Blocked transit lanes and stops directly impact transit reliability, accessibility, safety, and equity, he said. He added that a blocked bus stop can affect boarding for passengers who may need the wheelchair ramp and forces passengers to board in the street.
Transit advocates applauded the effort to keep the transit lanes and bus stops cleared.
Dylan Fabris, a community organizer with San Francisco Transit Riders, said there had been an influx of food delivery drivers parked in the transit lanes and bus tops.
“This is common sense to ensure that we’re not burning riders’ time and burning riders or and burning taxpayers’ money by forcing loaded buses, loaded trains to get stuck behind somebody’s burrito delivery or whatever.”
Marie Hurabiell with Connected SF said she had mixed feelings about the project. Hurabiell said while she understood that it could be “irritating” for a bus passenger to have the bus blocked in the transit lane, she added that more parking should be opened up, so drivers don’t have to park in the transit lane.
She also spoke about affordability and the penalties that drivers could receive from the citations.
The current fine for blocking a transit lane is $108 while the fine for blocking a bus stop is $443.
Julie Kirschbaum, the SFMTA’s director of transportation, said the agency plans to reevaluate the fine structure for the violations.
The SFMTA will first install the cameras on two buses in March of next year to test the new system and launch an educational campaign. The agency will then install the cameras on 212 buses as part of an initial deployment.
In May, the SFMTA will launch a 60-day warning period. After the warning period, the agency will start issuing citations in July.
