History has a way of repeating itself in a city more concerned with optics than with justice. I write now as a mother preparing to launch my young son into the world. Like Hanako, he dreams of living abroad in a city and country he has idealized for years. For Hanako, that city was San Francisco. She never made it home.

The deal, accepted by Judge Eric Fleming in November 2026, will result in a substantial sentence on paper but far less once credits for nearly six years already served are applied.

San Francisco still trades on its past magic — the Haight hippies, the cable-car hills, the majestic Victorians. Its nights and alleys tell a different story: fentanyl-laced escapism, drug-induced random assaults, and serial offenders who cycle through the system with little consequence. The city’s Jekyll-and-Hyde dysfunction is real. Arrests may be rising, but conviction and sentencing outcomes remain abysmal.

In 2025, San Francisco saw only about 24 percent of felony filings result in prison, felony probation, or jail sentences. Neighboring counties fared far better: Alameda roughly 43 percent San Mateo 47 percent, and Contra Costa 69 percent. More than three-quarters of San Francisco felony filings were dismissed, reduced to misdemeanors, diverted, acquitted, or left hanging because defendants skipped court.

Troy McAlister had a decades-long record that included more than 100 felony charges and prior strikes. Against the clear wishes of Hanako’s mother, Hiroko Abe, District Attorney Brooke Jenkins’s office (through Assistant District Attorney Kourtney Bell) accepted a plea to gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated. Prosecutors declined to pursue a malice-murder charge. The deal, accepted by Judge Eric Fleming in November 2026, will result in a substantial sentence on paper but far less once credits for nearly six years already served are applied. Mrs. Abe has said the district attorney’s office never treated her as a genuine victim advocate, only as a recipient of last-minute, one-sided emails announcing decisions already made. She also said Assistant District Attorney Bell told the judge the office would not accept a plea without her input, only for that to happen anyway.

Political insiders have noted that after the disappointing manslaughter-only outcome in the high-profile Grandpa Vicha trial, another public loss in the Abe case would have been costly for a district attorney aspiring for attorney general. Whether that calculation drove the decision, the result is the same: a mother who waited six years for a jury to hear the facts instead received a negotiated resolution she opposed. San Francisco crime victims continue to be the sacrificial lambs for the ambitions of higher office.

And again, history repeats itself as the nonprofits associated with the Stop AAPI Hate and related “Stop the Hate” ecosystem have received well over $100 million in California state funding (part of the roughly $156 million API Equity Budget package) while frequently advocating non-carceral, restorative approaches. Fundraising emails continue to flood my inbox even as families like the Abes experience the practical results of those philosophies. Meanwhile, San Francisco Superior Court has a documented history of incomplete or delayed reporting of judicial dispositions to the California Judicial Council, limiting public oversight.

I leave this with one final thought about my son, who dreams of living in Japan one day. I pray that life returns our children to us better than when we send them off. For the sake of transparency and truth, cities like San Francisco should show parents both the bright lights and the dark shadows, so they can make fully informed decisions when we launch them into the world.

Liz Le is an entrepreneur, research strategist, 20-year San Francisco resident, poli-sci/econ maverick, and parent of two teens.