The face of college sports – including at Bay Area universities — may drastically change if congressional Republicans and former tennis star Patrick McEnroe get their way. Two weeks after suffering devastating losses in the midterm elections, congressional Republicans believe they have hit a home run with the voters on the issues of immigration and foreign competition: Mandating a cap on the percentage of international students allowed on individual college sports teams. They want to reserve spots on college varsity teams for U.S. citizens or permanent residents and make it harder for student athletes to represent other countries at the Olympics.
At a Capitol Hill press conference on Wednesday emceed by McEnroe, House Education and Workforce Committee Chairman Tim Walberg (R-MI) highlighted his TEAM USA Act to require every college sports team to be composed of at least 80 percent United States citizens or permanent residents or risk being denied access to federal financial aid programs for their students. Chairman Walberg is the same member of Congress who summoned San Francisco Superintendent of Schools Maria Su and other big-city education leaders to Washington, D.C., in June. This time, his legislative effort will make many local colleges, including the University of San Francisco, Stanford, and St. Mary’s, ineligible to receive and distribute millions of dollars of federal student financial aid. Colleges are already feeling the economic impact of an 18 percent drop in new international students in 2025 as many rely on international students paying full tuition to subsidize financial aid for U.S. students.
The Walberg bill, H.R. 10351, and its Senate companion, S. 5392, authored by Senator Jon Husted (R-Ohio) and Senator Tommy Tuberville (R-Ala.), a retired college football coach, were introduced in September but were highlighted this week as an indication that the bills may be a Republican priority for inclusion in legislation attempted for passage in the waning days of the Republican-controlled Congress or be the subject of a Trump administration executive order this year or in the future. With the exception of Senator Husted, the bill’s sponsors and cosponsors will return for the next Congress in January.
Recruiting international athletes to U.S. colleges is a relatively new trend but a growing strategy. Half of the men’s basketball team and 60 percent of the women’s track and field team at the University of San Francisco are international students. Players from Australia have been critical to the St. Mary’s Gaels’ rise to national recognition as a college basketball powerhouse. Over half of this year’s team is international. Both schools tout their recruiting programs and services they provide to international student-athletes.
The Walberg bill would require universities to report to Washington, D.C. every year the percentage of international students on every varsity team roster. If these student-athletes exceed the 20 percent limit, the universities would be ineligible to administer federal financial aid to any of their students. Currently, three of the top five nationally ranked men’s basketball teams — Florida, Duke, and Connecticut — have more than 20 percent international student-athletes. At the Martin campus of the University of Tennessee, all but one of the 15 members of the men’s basketball team hails from abroad. The composition of Stanford’s men’s and women’s golf teams would conflict with another provision of the bill that limits small rosters to one international student-athlete. The bill also classifies DACA students as international. These students have lived in the United States for many years but arrived with their parents lacking legal immigration status.
International participation is greater in other college sports. According to Veronica Lee, CEO of Borderless, an international student counseling service, international students comprise over 60 percent of freshmen NCAA varsity tennis players, 40 percent of collegiate ice hockey players, and a quarter to a third of college golfers and soccer players. McEnroe became involved in the effort after watching conference championship tournaments with one or two U.S. players out of a dozen and complaining about it online. As McEnroe explained to Megyn Kelly in May, international student-athletes now effectively block the path he and other U.S. teenagers have taken for college tennis that starts at country clubs and tennis academies. The expansion of club teams have also driven up costs for aspiring U.S. soccer and baseball players.
According to McEnroe, U.S. colleges produce more Olympic athletes for other countries than U.S. Olympians. That concern might simply be a product of mathematics. While the U.S. had the largest team at the 2024 Summer Olympics, it fielded only 6 percent of the Olympians worldwide. Moreover, some athletes who have a choice opt to compete for teams whose country’s competition level is easier. Under NCAA rules, prospective Olympians are allowed to train more hours per week, so these international students gain an advantage. McEnroe also criticizes NCAA rules that allow athletes who have competed professionally in their home countries and are now older to compete in U.S. collegiate sports programs against younger athletes immediately out of high school.
The significance of the Walberg bill goes far beyond the college sports arena. Adjustments can be made to NCAA policies without congressional intervention or the threat to take away federal financial aid from all students. Just one in 16 high school athletes goes on to play for a college team. Intentionally or not, the Walberg bill revives the age-old resentment of foreign workers taking jobs away from Americans. Its remedy of a cap on international student-athletes is ironic, coming from a party that long criticized affirmative action as quotas and hailed equality of opportunity over equality of outcomes.
