Hanako photographed near the Golden Gate Bridge. | Photo courtesy of the Abe family

Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026, I spoke with Hiroko Abe over Zoom as we have done so many times over the past six years. Mrs. Abe, who lives in Japan, was assisted by Tasha Yorozu, an attorney who doesn’t represent Mrs. Abe but who has graciously volunteered to translate for her through every call and numerous court hearings. As she has over more than half a decade, Mrs. Abe remains softspoken yet incredibly strong in her convictions. 

This Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 1:30 p.m. Pacific Standard Time, the San Francisco District Attorney’s Office will propose to Dept. 26 presiding judge Eric Fleming that he allow them to accept a plea deal for Troy McAlister, the killer of Mrs. Abe’s daughter Hanako and a woman named Elizabeth Platt.

Members of the public can attend the hearing at Superior Court or watch it on Zoom here using meeting ID 160 6991 3087, password 443439. Mrs. Abe posted to X her feelings on the plea deal, as well as her hope that those who have supported her throughout the years will attend the hearing.

If Fleming doesn’t accept the plea, the case is scheduled for trial on November 20, 2026, but all indications are that he will go with the proposal hammered out between the offices of the District Attorney and the Public Defender.

Over the course of several months, Assistant District Attorney Kourtney Bell, who is assigned to the McAlister case, has insisted that the plea deal is the best outcome they can hope for, but Mrs. Abe told me that she continues to vehemently oppose the settlement. “I want the case to go to trial,” she said, “not because I want retribution, but because I feel McAlister should be judged by a jury of his peers. I understand that trial could result in a sentence shorter than the proposed agreement, and I fully accept that uncertainty.”

With Mrs. Abe remaining steadfast, Bell offered a meeting with District Attorney Brooke Jenkins, but Mrs. Abe told me a meeting with Jenkins doesn’t interest her, and that the timing felt suspect and political in nature. “Why now?” she asked. “DA Jenkins hasn’t contacted me once since she took office. Meeting her now isn’t going to change my mind.”

With the help of her translator, Mrs. Abe wrote letters to both ADA Bell and Judge Eric Fleming, which she shared with The Voice. Both letters are printed in their entirety at the end of this article. “I want the people of San Francisco, the city Hanako loved so much, to understand why I oppose the plea deal, and why I feel it is important for the trial to go on,” she said. 

The Abe family, left to right: Hana Abe, wife of Teruyuki, Hanako’s younger brother, who didn’t have a chance to meet Hanako. Sou Abe, Hanako’s nephew, born on the day Hanako passed away. Teruyuki Abe, Hanako’s brother, who is five years younger. Hanako took care of him through her mother’s illness. Tsuneo Abe, Hanako’s father, holding her photo. Hiroko Abe, Hanako’s mother, holding family dog, Boo. | Credit: Courtesy Abe family

HOW WE GOT HERE

Since McAlister started his adult criminal career in 1995, seven district attorneys and four public defenders have overseen his violent exploits and hundreds of thousands of taxpayer dollars have been devoted to his prosecution and defense. In 2015, then District Attorney George Gascon was against McAlister’s release after, high on meth and on parole, he committed another armed robbery. Gascon pointed out that McAlister had three allegations for prior strikes and six prison priors. “As a result of the charged offenses, the defendant’s exposure in State Prison is approximately thirty-five years to life in prison,” Gascon told the court. The judge agreed, and McAlister stayed in jail. In 2020, after Gascon left to run for Los Angeles district attorney, an inexperienced assistant public defender named Chesa Boudin, who ran on a radical social justice platform, was elected to replace him. Just three months into his tenure, Boudin negotiated a plea deal in which all strike enhancements were dropped, and McAlister was released on time served for the 2015 robbery charge.

Once free, McAlister went right back to his old ways and was arrested June 28, Aug. 20, Oct. 15, Nov. 6, and Dec. 20, for which he served a combined 11 days in jail. 

In the late afternoon of New Year’s Eve, 2020, McAlister, high on methamphetamine and fleeing from an armed robbery, crashed into another car and struck 27-year-old Hanako Abe and another woman, 60-year-old Elizabeth Platt, in the crosswalk at Second and Mission Streets.

McAlister fled the scene and hid in a nearby building, where police found and arrested him. Officers later discovered meth and a gun in the car. One day before the fatal crash, McAlister stole the vehicle from a woman he met on a dating app after brandishing a 9 mm pistol while they waited for food on their second date at Nation’s Giant Hamburgers in Daly City. 

Publicity from the case, and the release of McAlister’s prior arrests and life of crime helped galvanize the successful recall of Boudin, who had released the potential three-striker on a plea deal just months before. 

An unknown assistant district attorney named Brooke Jenkins began working on the Boudin recall campaign, which made the McAlister case a cornerstone of their movement. When Boudin was recalled on June 7, 2022, then Mayor London Breed appointed Jenkins as interim district attorney until a special election was held on November 8, 2022, at which time Jenkins was elected to the position. The McAlister case is arguably the most important case of her nascent career. 

In a Dec. 10, 2025 exclusive, The Voice of San Francisco revealed documents showing that the Dec. 31, 2020 crash that killed 60-year-old Elizabeth Platt and 27-year-old Hanako Abe in San Francisco was one of several incidents over six months that should have prompted agents and supervisors of the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR), Division of Adult Parole Operations (DAPO), and San Francisco Parole Unit 1 to issue a parole hold on parolee Troy McAlister. Three months after that report, Phoong Law Corporation, led by attorneys Anh Phoong and Diana Thomas, filed a government claim against the State of California on behalf of the Abe family, and on Oct. 8, 2026, a lawsuit was filed.

(TRANSLATED LETTER FROM MRS. HIROKO ABE TO A.D.A. BELL FOLLOWS)

Dear Mr. Bell,

Thank you for your email and for taking the time to respond to my questions.

I remain perplexed that the District Attorney’s office has repeatedly shifted the focus away from my straightforward questions rather than answering them directly.  The information and responses your office provided to me have deepened, rather than resolved, my concerns about the proposed plea agreement.  It appears as though the District Attorney’s office has already determined to close out this case through a plea agreement, as stated in your October 7 email message to me. 

After much thought, and carefully reviewing your responses and everything I have learned about the proposed plea agreement, I have concluded that I do not wish to continue asking further questions.  My concern is no longer whether additional explanations from the District Attorney’s office might persuade me that the proposed plea agreement is appropriate.  They will not, for the same reasons I conveyed to you on October 8 and in this letter.

I remain firmly opposed to closing out this case through the proposed plea agreement.

As I have consistently tried to convey, my position is not based on retribution, nor is it about seeking the longest possible prison sentence for Mr. McAlister.  I understand that a trial involves uncertainty and could ultimately result in a sentence shorter than the proposed agreement.  I accept that possibility. My concern is more fundamental:  after nearly six years, I believe this case should be heard and decided through the criminal justice process in an open courtroom, where the evidence can be presented, and members of the San Francisco community can serve as jurors and determine the outcome. That is particularly important to me because this case concerns not only the deaths of Hanako and Ms. Elizabeth Platt, but also broader questions about justice, public safety, accountability, and confidence in our justice system.

The information I recently received has only strengthened that conviction.  I learned for the first time on November 6 that the approximate maximum possible sentence may be 38 years and 4 months, when I had previously understood from our October 5 meeting that the sentencing exposure after trial was approximately 24 years.  I also learned that significant charging decisions were made concerning the Watson implied-malice murder charge and the Three Strikes Law.  There remain other aspects of the history of this prosecution that deeply concern me.  In an effort to gain further clarity, I asked straightforward questions, but several questions remain unanswered: 

Why did the District Attorney’s office decline to add a Watson implied-malice murder charge when the judge raised that possibility, particularly if the reason was that doing so would require transferring the case to the Attorney General’s office?

What were the advantages and disadvantages considered by the District Attorney’s office in deciding to retain the case rather than transfer it?

Which underlying conviction will Mr. McAlister admit as the prior strike under the plea agreement?

Given the approximately 12 years of custody credits already accumulated, what is the anticipated practical effect of the proposed sentence, and how does the District Attorney’s office believe that result provides appropriate accountability for the loss of two lives?

But at this point, after much thought and reflection, I do not believe that further explanations or answers from your office, or a meeting with District Attorney Brooke Jenkins, from whom I have not heard since she took office, would change my position.  Regardless of whether I agree or disagree with the reasons behind those decisions that have been made, I believe this case should be resolved by a jury in an open courtroom, not through a plea agreement.

I have therefore prepared a separate statement to Judge Fleming explaining why I respectfully ask the Court to reject the proposed plea agreement and allow the case to proceed to trial.  I would like to have the English-translated version of my statement read aloud on my behalf by my friend Tasha Yorozu.

Please ensure that my opposition is communicated to everyone involved in making this decision and made part of the record.  I also respectfully request that a copy of this letter be provided to Judge Fleming before today’s 1:30 pm hearing. 

Please do not characterize the proposed plea agreement as having my support or as an outcome reached on behalf of my family.  We respectfully oppose its acceptance.

I appreciate the time you have spent speaking with me and responding to my concerns.  I know that we may see this matter differently.  I nevertheless hope you will understand that my position comes from a deeply held belief about what justice the people of San Francisco and everyone requires, not only for Hanako and Ms. Platt, but for the community they were part of.

Sincerely,

Hiroko Abe

Mother of Hanako Abe

November 10, 2026

(END OF LETTER TO A.D.A. BELL)

(TRANSLATION OF MRS. HIROKO ABE’S LETTER TO JUDGE FLEMING)

Re:  People v. McAlister: Statement in Opposition to the Proposed Plea Agreement

Dear Judge Fleming:

I am the mother of Hanako Abe, one of the victims in this case.  I am deeply grateful for the opportunity to address the Court as a mother who lost her daughter, a young woman who loved San Francisco.  I respectfully ask the Court to reject the proposed plea agreement and allow this case to proceed to trial. 

Since Hanako’s life was suddenly taken from us, it has felt as though time has stood still.  Her dreams and aspirations for the future, the precious years she should have shared with her family, and above all, her precious life itself were taken from her suddenly and violently.  There are no words to describe the sorrow of losing my beloved daughter. 

Yet I do not come before the Court consumed only by grief, nor am I seeking retribution against Mr. McAlister.  My deepest hope is that Hanako’s death will not be in vain and that, from this profound tragedy, a path toward renewal and contribution to society may emerge. 

Through all that has happened since losing Hanako, and through the support I have received from the people of San Francisco and the broader community, I have reached one deeply held conviction:  meaningful change becomes possible when residents seek to understand what happens in their community and personally become involved in making it safer and more transparent. 

In daily conversations, Hanako often spoke of her passion to help make San Francisco safer and a more beautiful city.  Hanako loved life, loved her family, and loved San Francisco.  Now that Hanako is gone, I believe I have been entrusted with carrying forward that love and purpose. 

It is from this perspective that I oppose the proposed plea agreement.

If a case with consequences this grave is resolved through negotiation without a public trial, I fear that the people of San Francisco may lose an important opportunity to understand the true danger and seriousness of what occurred. 

There is profound value in citizens serving as jurors, confronting the facts and evidence directly and solemnly, and determining the outcome in an open courtroom.  Through that process, the tragedy suffered by Hanako and Ms. Elizabeth Platt becomes one in which the community can face as its own, recognizing that either victim could have been someone they loved.  A public trial also allows the community to consider how such tragedies can be prevented, what standards our laws and society should uphold, and what each of us can do to make our beloved community safer. 

I understand that plea agreements serve an important function in the criminal justice system by reducing the burdens and uncertainties of trial.  But when efficiency and certainty come at the cost of truth, the families’ ability to understand what happened, and accountability to the community, public confidence in the justice system may be weakened.  This will not serve Justice to the people of San Francisco.   

Nearly six years have passed since Hanako and Ms. Platt lost their lives.  What is needed now is a transparent judicial process in which the District Attorney’s decisions can be understood, the facts and evidence are brought into the open, and jurors from the community are entrusted to consider them.  This way, families and the community can see for themselves how justice is carried out.  I believe this will serve Justice. 

This case has meaning beyond the disposition of one criminal case.  It carries broader significance for the safety and future of San Francisco and the value that our society places upon human life.

Why I Continue to Oppose the Proposed Plea 

I understand that I do not determine how this prosecution should be resolved.  I also understand that trial carries risk and could result in a sentence shorter than the proposed agreement.  I fully accept that uncertainty. 

As I explained in my October 8 letter, my opposition has never been about retribution or obtaining the longest possible prison sentence.  It is about transparency, accountability, public participation, and the hope that what happened to Hanako and Ms. Platt may help create a safer community.  It is about justice in its broader meaning, not only justice for Hanako and Ms. Platt. 

I sincerely appreciate the time Mr. Bell has taken to respond to my questions.  However, some of the information I have received has deepened, rather than resolved, my concerns. 

The Maximum Possible Sentence Has Significantly Changed 

At our October 5 meeting, my first substantive meeting with the District Attorney’s office, I understood Mr. Bell to say that the proposed 20-year sentence was close to the realistic sentencing exposure after trial, described as approximately 24 years, and that the plea offer was therefore sound.  On November 6, however, Mr. Bell stated in his email response that the approximate maximum possible sentence is 38 years and 4 months, depending on the Court’s exercise of sentencing discretion. 

I understand that this is a maximum, not a prediction of the sentence the Court would impose.  Even so, the difference is substantial, changing my understanding of what may be relinquished through the proposed plea. 

The agreement’s practical effect also remains uncertain.  The District Attorney’s office advised that Mr. McAlister has accumulated approximately 12 years of custody credits, but cannot reliably predict how much additional time he will serve.  I respectfully ask the Court to consider these facts in determining whether the agreement provides appropriate accountability. 

The District Attorney’s Office Has Stated That the Case Is Ready for Trial 

On October 5, Mr. Bell explained that the prosecution had prevailed on significant pretrial matters, including mental-health diversion, suppression of evidence, and the Penal Code section 995 motion.  He described the defense as having reached the ‘end of the road,’ with trial essentially all that remained, and explained that the principal benefit of a plea was certainty as to the sentence.  On October 7, Mr. Bell informed me that the District Attorney’s office had determined to accept the plea agreement. 

I understand why both sides may wish to avoid the uncertainty of trial.  But uncertainty exists in every trial.  If this case is ready to be presented to San Francisco jurors, I respectfully question whether certainty alone is sufficient reason to end it without allowing a jury to ever hear the evidence and determine the result. 

Unanswered Questions About the Charging Document History 

Mr. Bell explained on October 5 that, given Mr. McAlister’s criminal history, he should have been subject to the Three Strikes Law, but was not because of political reasons and the policies of former District Attorney Chesa Boudin. 

Mr. Bell also stated that, before the 2025 indictment, the judge asked whether the current District Attorney’s office wished to add a Watson implied-malice murder charge.  The District Attorney’s office declined because doing so would have required transferring the case to the Attorney General’s Office.  Mr. Bell said their office wanted to retain the case because it occurred in San Francisco.  My later questions about the basis and the pros and cons for that decision were not answered in the November 6 response. 

I recognize that I am not in a position to determine the prosecutors’ motives, and I do not ask the Court to infer the appropriateness of the motives.  These circumstances nevertheless leave serious unanswered questions about whether considerations unrelated to the merits affected the handling of the case.  A plea agreement would end the case without those questions being brought up in an open courtroom. 

I also remain troubled by reports of the circumstances surrounding District Attorney Brooke Jenkins’s handling and forwarding of information relating to this case to a friend’s private email while she was campaigning for Mr. Boudin’s recall.  This is not collateral to me.  My daughter’s death and this prosecution should never become instruments of politics or personal advancement. 

Again, I do not ask the Court to make findings based on my concerns alone.  Rather, the cumulative history of this case makes public accountability more important, not less.  The people of San Francisco should be able to trust that decisions concerning two deaths were guided by evidence and law, not by institutional, political, or personal considerations.

Unanswered Question About the Prior Strike 

When I asked Mr. Bell which prior conviction Mr. McAlister would admit as a strike under the plea agreement, I did not receive a direct answer.  The November 6 response states that he will admit a strike allegation charged in the case, but it does not identify the underlying conviction. 

I do not raise these questions to accuse anyone of wrongdoing.  I simply believe that, before a case involving two lost lives is permanently closed out without a jury trial, there should be clarity about the charges and enhancements being relinquished, the strike being admitted, and the agreement’s actual consequences. 

At the same time, after much thought and reflection, I do not believe that further explanations or responses from the District Attorney’s office will change my position that the appropriate place for resolving this case is a jury trial in an open courtroom. 

My Request to the Court 

I understand that the prosecution and defense negotiated this agreement and that, as Hanako’s mother, I do not control whether it is accepted.  I therefore respectfully ask the Court to exercise its independent judgment, reject the proposed plea agreement, and allow the case to proceed through the criminal justice process before a jury in open court. 

My deepest hope is that, from the tragedy of losing Hanako, a path may emerge toward renewal and contribution to society, and that the life she lived may continue in some meaningful way to contribute to the safety and fairness of the society she loved.  That is the mission I believe Hanako has left to me. 

If the Court nevertheless accepts the plea agreement, I respectfully ask that this letter become a part of the record reflecting that Hanako’s family does not support it and that it was not reached on our behalf. 

Thank you for listening to me, for reading my prior letter on October 8, and for the respect you have shown Hanako, my family, and me throughout this process. 

I sincerely hope that justice worthy of the community’s trust will prevail, and that Hanako’s life and memory will contribute to a safer, more transparent, and more just society.

 With respect and appreciation, 

Hiroko Abe

Mother of Hanako Abe 

November 10, 2026

(END OF TRANSLATION OF MRS. ABE’S EMAIL TO JUDGE FLEMING)

Susan Dyer Reynolds is the editorial director of The Voice of San Francisco and an award-winning journalist. Follow her on X @TheVOSF.